COBRA vs. ACA Marketplace in 2027: What Losing Employer Coverage Will Cost

In the COBRA vs Marketplace decision after you lose employer coverage in 2027, COBRA could run about $833 a month for single coverage and about $2,406 a month for a family, based on 2026 averages from KFF’s Employer Health Benefits Survey, while an ACA Marketplace plan could cost far less or far more depending on your income. The COBRA vs Marketplace choice matters more this year because Marketplace benchmark premiums are rising another 13% for 2027 and the rules for enrolling outside open enrollment have tightened.

Your own COBRA notice will give the actual price, since these figures are national averages built from 2026 premiums. Use them to see the scale of the COBRA vs Marketplace decision, not as a quote.

What does losing employer coverage trigger?

Losing a job, having your hours cut below benefits eligibility, or your employer dropping its health plan all count as a qualifying life event. That gives you two options with separate 60-day windows: elect COBRA continuation coverage through your former employer’s plan, or shop for a Marketplace plan through a Special Enrollment Period on HealthCare.gov.

One change for 2027: the monthly enrollment window for people with incomes below 150% of the federal poverty level is no longer available, according to Becker’s coverage of the CMS rule. Outside open enrollment, you now need a qualifying event, such as losing job-based coverage, to enroll.

How much does COBRA cost in 2027?

COBRA lets you keep your exact former plan, but you pay the full premium yourself, plus up to a 2% administrative fee, because your employer stops contributing. KFF’s 2026 survey puts the average annual premium at $9,804 for single coverage and $28,303 for family coverage. At 102% of those figures, COBRA averages roughly $833 a month for one person and $2,406 a month for a family.

That is a steep jump from what you were likely paying as an employee. Covered workers contributed an average of $1,672 a year toward single coverage ($139 a month) and $7,471 a year toward family coverage ($623 a month) in 2026, with employers paying the rest. For a deeper breakdown of why COBRA costs this much, see our post on the COBRA math.

How much does a Marketplace plan cost in 2027?

The Marketplace is usually the cheaper path after job loss, but how much cheaper depends on your household income, because COBRA has no income-based discount and a Marketplace plan can. According to KFF, the national average benchmark Silver premium for 2027 is $703 a month for a 40-year-old before any subsidy, and the average lowest-cost Silver premium is $681. Marketplace premiums rise with age, so a person in their 50s or 60s above the subsidy cliff may pay more than these averages. Both are up from 2026, part of a second year of double-digit increases (benchmark premiums rose 26% for 2026 and 13% for 2027).

If your household income qualifies for a premium tax credit, your cost is capped as a share of income rather than tied to the sticker price.

What does the 2027 subsidy cliff look like in dollars?

Premium tax credits are available for households between 100% and 400% of the federal poverty level, and the 400% line is a hard cutoff, not a gradual phase-out. For 2027 coverage, 400% works out to $63,840 for one person and $132,000 for a family of four. A household at exactly 400% is expected to pay up to 10.22% of income for the benchmark Silver plan, or about $544 a month for a single person near the top of the range. Above the cliff there is no federal premium tax credit at all, as explained in our guide to the ACA subsidy cliff.

In the COBRA vs Marketplace math, job loss can cut both ways. If your household income drops sharply after a layoff, you may qualify for a much larger subsidy than you ever saw while employed, sometimes bringing a Marketplace plan down to a fraction of the COBRA price. If your household still has other income, such as a spouse’s paycheck or severance counted in the same tax year, you may land above the cliff and face the full premium.

How does COBRA vs Marketplace compare beyond price?

Premium is only one part of the COBRA vs Marketplace comparison.

  • COBRA keeps your exact plan, deductible progress, and provider network with no gap in coverage, which matters if you are mid-treatment or close to meeting your deductible.
  • A Marketplace plan resets your deductible and may use a different network, but it opens the door to a subsidy that COBRA never offers.
  • You generally cannot get premium tax credits for any month you are enrolled in COBRA, and dropping COBRA voluntarily generally does not open a new Special Enrollment Period. Compare the two before you elect COBRA, not after.

Run the COBRA vs Marketplace numbers for your household using a tool that lets you compare your coverage options by state and income before you let the COBRA election deadline pass by default.

What timing rules apply to COBRA vs Marketplace?

Timing is where most of the avoidable gaps happen.

  1. Marketplace: you can enroll before you lose coverage. A Special Enrollment Period generally runs 60 days before and 60 days after the loss of job-based coverage. Choosing a plan before the loss date generally lets coverage start the first of the month after your employer coverage ends. Choosing after the loss can leave a gap, because coverage generally starts the first of the month after you select a plan.
  2. COBRA: The 60-day election window runs from the later of your coverage loss or your election notice. Coverage is retroactive to the loss date if you elect later in the 60-day window and pay the back premiums, and it generally lasts up to 18 months for job loss or reduced hours.
  3. Bring proof. CMS is reinstating pre-enrollment verification for Special Enrollment Periods, so have documents showing your loss of coverage ready when you apply.
  4. Check the open enrollment calendar. If your coverage ends near year-end, open enrollment for 2027 coverage runs through January 15, 2027, and December 15 is the deadline for January 1 coverage on HealthCare.gov; state marketplaces may differ. Confirm current dates at HealthCare.gov. See open enrollment 2027 dates and deadlines.
  5. Check Medicaid. If your income drops sharply, you may qualify for Medicaid depending on your state.

What if neither COBRA nor a full-price Marketplace plan fits your budget?

For households above the subsidy cliff, or anyone who wants a lower fixed monthly cost while between jobs, a few other paths exist. None replace a full ACA plan’s guaranteed issue and essential health benefits, so understand the trade-offs first.

Modern Health Sharing is one option worth understanding on its own terms. In a modern Health Sharing arrangement, members contribute a monthly amount, and the group helps cover eligible medical bills among its members. A Health Share is not insurance and is not minimum essential coverage under the ACA. It is regulated differently than insurance, not left unregulated, and it operates under published Member Guidelines rather than an insurance contract. Monthly contributions can be lower than an unsubsidized Marketplace premium for some households, depending on the organization, your age, and your sharing level. Our guide to how cost sharing works in a Health Share explains the mechanics.

A Health Share does not guarantee payment of any specific bill, and it typically applies waiting periods for pre-existing conditions. Insurance has limits too: according to KFF’s analysis of CMS data, HealthCare.gov insurers denied 19% of in-network claims and 37% of out-of-network claims in 2024, and fewer than 1% of denied in-network claims were appealed. Health Sharing organizations differ in how long they have operated, their waiting periods, and their sharing limits, so ask for those terms in writing.

Pairing Direct Primary Care with a Health Share is a common combination: Direct Primary Care covers routine and preventive visits for a flat monthly fee, while a Health Share is positioned for larger, unplanned events. Other options include short-term medical insurance for a brief gap, MEC plans that cover preventive care at low cost, and virtual care memberships.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to decide COBRA vs Marketplace right away? No, but both windows run on a clock. You generally have 60 days to elect COBRA and 60 days after the loss to enroll in a Marketplace plan, and you can start a Marketplace enrollment up to 60 days before coverage ends. Delaying can create a gap, so compare costs early.

Will I automatically get a subsidy if I lose my job and buy a Marketplace plan? No. Your premium tax credit is based on your estimated household income for the full year. A job loss can lower that estimate and raise your subsidy, but you must apply and report the updated figure through HealthCare.gov or your state exchange.

Can I get a Marketplace subsidy while I am on COBRA? Generally no. You cannot receive premium tax credits for months you are enrolled in COBRA, and voluntarily dropping COBRA generally does not open a new Special Enrollment Period. Compare your options before you elect.

Is COBRA ever the better choice even though it costs more? It can be, particularly if you are mid-treatment, close to meeting a high deductible, or need a specialist who is not in any Marketplace network available to you, since COBRA preserves your exact prior plan with no deductible reset.

Can I use a Health Share instead of COBRA or a Marketplace plan? You can, but a Health Share is cost sharing among members rather than insurance, is not minimum essential coverage, and does not guarantee payment of any bill. It can be a reasonably lower-cost option for some households if you understand its waiting periods and Member Guidelines first.

What happens if I do nothing after losing employer coverage? If both your COBRA election window and your Special Enrollment Period expire, you will likely be uninsured until the next open enrollment period, which for 2027 coverage runs November 1, 2026 through January 15, 2027 on HealthCare.gov, with December 15 as the deadline for January 1 coverage; state marketplaces may differ. Confirm current dates at HealthCare.gov.


This article is for general informational purposes only and is not insurance, legal, tax or financial advice. COBRA and employer premium figures come from KFF’s 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey, published October 2026. Marketplace premium figures come from KFF’s average premiums by metal tier for 2027, and the 2027 subsidy cliff uses the 2026 federal poverty guidelines. Special Enrollment Period rules reflect CMS’s 2027 marketplace rule as reported by Becker’s. Claims denial figures come from KFF’s analysis of 2024 CMS data, published March 2026. Health Sharing arrangements are not insurance and do not guarantee payment of any bill. All information is current as of November 2026. Confirm your COBRA election deadline and premium with your former employer’s plan administrator, and your Special Enrollment Period and subsidy eligibility at HealthCare.gov, before deciding.

By the Modern Healthcare Works team