Denied: How ACA Claim Appeals Work — and How Health Share Bill Negotiation Differs

When an ACA Marketplace insurer denies a claim, you have a federally guaranteed right to appeal that decision through an internal review and, if necessary, an independent external review by a third party, and those appeals succeed more often than most people realize, yet fewer than 1% of denied claims are ever appealed.

When a health share declines to apply community funds to a submitted need, the process looks different but the opportunity to resolve it is equally real: health shares typically have their own member review and advocacy processes, and many well-established organizations offer direct member support that can negotiate provider bills, clarify guideline questions, and help members navigate the process in ways that a large insurer’s call center often cannot. This post explains both systems clearly so you know what to do when something is denied or declined, regardless of which type of coverage you have.

How common are ACA claim denials, and what causes them?

ACA Marketplace claim denials are more common than most enrollees realize. According to KFF’s analysis of CMS Transparency in Coverage data, insurers selling Qualified Health Plans on HealthCare.gov denied 19% of in-network claims and 37% of out-of-network claims in 2024, for a combined average of approximately 20% of all claims submitted. That is consistent with the 2023 rate and represents the highest denial rate since ACA Marketplace plans launched in 2015.

Among the insurers reporting data, individual denial rates ranged from 3% to 36% for in-network claims, reflecting significant variation by company and state. According to Becker’s Payer Issues reporting on the same KFF data, the most common denial reasons reported in 2024 were unlisted “other” reasons at 36% and administrative reasons at 25%, with lack of prior authorization or referral accounting for 9% and lack of medical necessity accounting for only 5%. This breakdown matters because it suggests a large share of denials are procedural or administrative rather than substantive coverage disputes, which means many are potentially reversible on appeal.

According to a January 2026 KFF poll, one-third of insured adults said they had experienced a health insurance company denying coverage for a service or medication their doctor prescribed in the past two years, and two-thirds considered delays and denials a major problem. Despite this, only one in ten adults who experienced a problem with their insurance had filed a formal appeal.

What is an internal appeal, and how do you file one?

An internal appeal is a formal request to your health insurer to review and reconsider a claim denial, and the ACA requires all non-grandfathered health plans to have a standardized internal appeal process. When your insurer denies a claim, it must send you an Explanation of Benefits (EOB) or denial notice that includes the specific reason for the denial and clear instructions for how to file an appeal.

The timeline matters. Under ACA regulations, you generally have 180 days from the date on your denial notice to file an internal appeal, according to CMS’s internal claims and appeals guidance. For urgent or ongoing care situations, you can request an expedited appeal, which requires a decision within 72 hours. For pre-service appeals (before you receive care), insurers typically have 30 days to decide. For post-service appeals (after care has been delivered), the standard window is 60 days.

When you file an internal appeal, include the denial notice, the EOB, any supporting clinical documentation from your provider, a letter from your doctor explaining why the service was medically necessary, and any relevant medical records. The more complete your documentation at the internal appeal stage, the stronger your position, both for the internal review itself and for any subsequent external review. According to ClaimCure’s aggregation of KFF and CMS appeal data, when consumers did appeal denied in-network ACA claims in 2023, insurers overturned approximately 44% of those denials in the consumer’s favor through internal review alone, a meaningfully higher success rate than most people assume.

What is an external review, and when can you request one?

If your insurer upholds the denial through the internal appeal process, you generally have the right to request an independent external review by a third-party organization that is not affiliated with your insurer. External review is a key ACA consumer protection and applies to most coverage denials involving medical judgment.

You typically have four months from the date your internal appeal is denied to request external review, according to CMS external review regulations. The external reviewer, called an Independent Review Organization (IRO), is assigned randomly from a certified list and must make its decision based on clinical evidence and coverage terms, not insurer policy.

The external review success rate is significant. According to KFF’s external review data and aggregate state Department of Insurance reports cited by ClaimCure, independent external review agencies overturn roughly 40% to 50% of the denials they evaluate, a meaningful second chance that most consumers never access. Of the approximately 85 million in-network denied claims in 2024, only 262,982 were internally appealed (fewer than 1%), and only 5,881 reached external review (4% of upheld internal appeals), according to the KFF 2024 claims and appeals analysis. The gap between how many denials could be appealed and how many actually are represents an enormous amount of coverage that consumers are leaving on the table.

What should I do practically when a claim is denied?

The most important step is to read the denial notice carefully before doing anything else. The denial reason determines your appeal strategy: an administrative denial for a missing prior authorization requires a different response than a medical necessity denial. Confirm that the denial reason matches your actual situation, since administrative errors in the denial itself are not uncommon.

Then follow these steps in order:

Step 1: Contact your provider. Many claim denials are resolved before a formal appeal when the provider resubmits the claim with corrected coding, additional documentation, or a prior authorization that was inadvertently omitted. Ask the billing department whether the denial is something they can fix on their end before you file a formal appeal yourself.

Step 2: File an internal appeal in writing. Request a formal internal appeal in writing, not just by phone. Include your denial notice, EOB, a letter from your treating physician explaining medical necessity, and any clinical guidelines or published medical literature your doctor can provide supporting the treatment. Keep copies of everything you submit and note the date.

Step 3: If the internal appeal is denied, request external review. Don’t stop at the internal appeal. Given the 40% to 50% external review overturn rate, filing for independent review is consistently underutilized by consumers and is the strongest tool available once the insurer has upheld its own denial.

Step 4: File a complaint with your state insurance commissioner. Filing a complaint with your state’s Department of Insurance does two things: it creates an official record that regulators track, and it sometimes accelerates resolution because insurers treat regulatory inquiries differently than individual member appeals.

How does a health share handle a declined need, and how is that different?

When a health share declines to apply community funds to a submitted need, the structure of recourse is different from an insurance appeal process, though in practice many reputable organizations have established review processes that function similarly in outcome.

Health shares are not insurance, and no federal law requires them to have the same internal and external appeal infrastructure that ACA plans are mandated to maintain. Their obligation runs to their own written Member Guidelines, which define what is eligible, what is excluded, and what review process applies when a need is submitted and not approved. Reading those guidelines is the first step to understanding what recourse exists at any specific organization, since the process varies meaningfully between organizations in ways that ACA insurance plans’ mandated processes do not.

That said, reputable health sharing organizations with long operating histories typically offer member review processes that allow members to request a second look at a declined need, submit additional documentation, and in some cases escalate to a committee or advocacy team. This is where the direct member support that reputable health shares often provide becomes particularly valuable: a knowledgeable representative who can walk through a specific guideline question, contact the provider to discuss billing, or help a member understand what additional documentation might change an eligibility determination is often more accessible at an established health share than at a large insurer routing calls through an outsourced call center.

What is health share bill negotiation, and how does it work?

This is one of the most practical and least-publicized advantages of membership in a well-run health sharing organization, and it works differently from anything in the ACA insurance framework. Health share members present themselves to providers as self-pay patients rather than insured patients, which means they are charged at or near cash-pay rates rather than at the chargemaster rates that insurers and health shares typically negotiate down. Because the health share is not submitting a claim to an insurance billing system, many providers are willing to offer immediate, substantial discounts to self-pay patients who can pay promptly.

Many established health sharing organizations have dedicated advocacy or member services teams that actively negotiate provider bills on behalf of members, contacting hospitals and specialists directly to request itemized bills, identify billing errors (which are common, particularly in hospital bills), negotiate discounts, and arrange payment plans when costs exceed a member’s immediate capacity. This advocacy function replaces the insurer’s claim processing role but often produces results that are more visible and more responsive to the member specifically because the member is the direct party rather than a number in a claims queue.

The process also varies by need type. For planned procedures, many health shares encourage or require members to request a Good Faith Estimate from the provider before care begins, negotiate the estimated cost in advance, and confirm the need’s eligibility under the Member Guidelines before proceeding. This front-end process, which has no direct equivalent in standard insurance, gives members more control over their costs before they commit to a procedure.

What are the most common reasons each system declines coverage, and are they reversible?

For ACA plans, the most common denial reasons in 2024 were administrative or procedural (missing prior authorization at 9%, administrative reasons at 25%, and unlisted “other” reasons at 36%), with medical necessity accounting for only 5%, according to the KFF data. This means the majority of ACA denials are potentially reversible through resubmission, corrected coding, or documentation of prior authorization that was obtained but not properly recorded, without even needing a formal appeal.

For health shares, the most common reasons a submitted need might not be approved include a pre-existing condition falling within the waiting period, a service category that is explicitly excluded under the organization’s guidelines, missing or incomplete documentation of the need, a provider billing code that doesn’t match the member’s submitted need description, or a need that exceeds the organization’s sharing limits for that category. Unlike ACA administrative denials, pre-existing condition waiting period issues are generally not reversible through the review process, since the waiting period is a structural feature of the membership rather than an administrative error. Documentation issues, billing code mismatches, and limit interpretations are more commonly resolvable through the member review process, and submitting additional supporting information from the treating provider is the most reliable way to strengthen a declined need submission.


JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Buying your own coverage? You don’t have to figure it out alone.

Ask questions, compare notes and see what others are paying in our free Facebook group, get one plain-English email when something changes, or watch the 60-second explainers.

Join the Facebook group Get the newsletter Subscribe on YouTube

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I have to appeal a denied ACA claim? Under ACA regulations, you generally have 180 days from the date on your denial notice to file an internal appeal, according to CMS’s internal appeals guidance. If the internal appeal is upheld, you typically have four months from that date to request external review. For urgent care situations involving immediate health risk, you can request an expedited appeal that requires a decision within 72 hours. Always check your specific denial notice, since the deadline and instructions are required to be stated clearly on the notice itself.

What percentage of ACA claim denials are successfully overturned on appeal? The data is more encouraging than most people assume. According to KFF’s 2024 analysis and ClaimCure’s aggregation of state external review reports, approximately 44% of internal appeals were overturned in consumers’ favor in 2023, and independent external reviewers overturn roughly 40% to 50% of the denials they evaluate. The catch is that fewer than 1% of denied claims are ever appealed, meaning most of that success potential goes unused.

Does a health share have to follow the same appeal rules as an ACA plan? No. Health shares are not insurance and are not subject to the ACA’s mandated internal and external appeal infrastructure. Their review process is governed by their own Member Guidelines. Reputable established health shares do have member review processes, but the specific steps, timelines, and escalation paths vary by organization. Reading the Member Guidelines carefully before joining, specifically the sections on the review and appeal process for declined needs, is the most reliable way to understand what recourse is available at any specific organization.

What is prior authorization, and why does it cause so many denials? Prior authorization is a requirement that certain services, medications, or procedures be approved by the insurer before they are provided. According to KFF, lack of prior authorization or referral accounted for 9% of ACA Marketplace denials in 2024. Prior authorization denials are some of the most commonly overturned on appeal, particularly when a physician can document that the service was medically necessary and that the authorization requirement was either obtained but not recorded or waived under the plan’s emergency provisions. As of January 2026, several major insurers voluntarily committed to reducing prior authorization requirements, though the scope and implementation of those changes varies by insurer.

Can I file a complaint with my state insurance commissioner about a denied claim? Yes, and doing so is often worth it even if you are also pursuing a formal appeal. State insurance commissioner offices track complaints by insurer and service type, and a regulatory inquiry can sometimes produce faster resolution than the formal appeal process alone. Your state’s Department of Insurance website has a complaint filing portal, and CMS also accepts complaints about ACA Marketplace insurers through HealthCare.gov. Health share members whose needs are declined can similarly file complaints with their state’s attorney general office, which is the primary regulatory oversight mechanism for health sharing organizations.

Is there any professional help available for appealing a denial? Yes. Patient advocates, insurance brokers, and healthcare navigators can all assist with the appeals process. Patient advocacy organizations exist specifically to help consumers navigate complex denials, particularly for serious diagnoses. Your employer’s HR department can sometimes assist with employer-plan appeals. For health share members, the organization’s own member services team is typically the first resource, and established organizations often have experienced advocates who can help navigate a declined need through the review process.


This article is for general informational purposes only and is not insurance, legal, or financial advice. Appeal rights, timelines, and procedures described here are based on ACA regulations and KFF analysis of CMS Transparency in Coverage data, current as of 2026. Health share review processes vary by organization and are governed by each organization’s Member Guidelines. Always read your specific denial notice carefully for deadlines and instructions, and consult your state’s Department of Insurance or a licensed patient advocate for assistance with complex denials.

By the Modern Healthcare Works team