Florida PBM Penalties: 13 PBMs Fined Over $12.66 Million, and What It Means for Your Prescriptions

Florida PBM penalties totaled more than $12.66 million in November 2026, when the state’s Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR) fined 13 pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) for violations of state PBM rules. The penalties matter because PBMs sit between your health plan and your pharmacy. How they operate affects what you pay at the counter and whether your neighborhood pharmacy stays open.

What are the Florida PBM penalties?

On November 9, 2026, Florida Insurance Commissioner Mike Yaworsky announced that OIR had completed market conduct examinations of PBMs and issued penalties totaling more than $12.66 million. According to Insurance Business and Becker’s Payer Issues, 13 PBMs were penalized, with individual fines ranging from $5,000 to $2.415 million. Commissioner Yaworsky said Florida needs “transparency and accountability for all Pharmacy Benefit Managers in Florida.”

What is a pharmacy benefit manager, and why does Florida regulate them?

A PBM is a company that administers prescription drug benefits for a health plan or employer. PBMs help decide which drugs are covered, which pharmacies are in the network, and how payments flow between drug manufacturers, pharmacies and insurers.

Florida’s 2023 Prescription Drug Reform Act gave OIR authority to regulate and examine PBMs. You can find the state’s rules and reports on the OIR pharmacy benefit manager page.

What did the examinations find?

OIR’s examinations cited violations in four areas:

  • Fair pricing models
  • Network adequacy and fair access
  • Pharmacy remittances
  • The prohibition on unilateral changes to pharmacy contracts

The reporting does not break down how many violations involved missing contract terms and how many involved documented conduct, so the findings should not be read as proof of any specific harm to patients.

Which companies face Florida PBM penalties, and how much?

Six PBMs received penalties of $1 million or more:

  • Employee Health Insurance Management: $2.415 million
  • Scrip World (CVS Health): $2.23 million
  • Right Rx FL: $2.115 million
  • ProAct: $1.845 million
  • Capital Rx (now Judi Health): $1.59 million
  • Slate Rx: $1.36 million

The other seven were Drexi ($355,000), PerformRx ($335,000), MC-21 Healthcare ($310,000), Benecard Services ($60,000), CarelonRx ($20,000), Prime Therapeutics Management ($20,000) and Prime Therapeutics ($5,000). Several of the penalized PBMs are contesting the findings in court, and OIR says more examinations are on the way.

Is this part of a bigger pattern of PBM scrutiny?

Yes, in Florida and in other states.

In Florida, an earlier OIR examinations summary reported by The Capitolist in early 2026 found that eight PBM examinations were impeded and that 20 PBMs collectively owed about $487,700 in unpaid examination costs. Separately, in August 2026, Attorney General James Uthmeier sued Prime Therapeutics and Express Scripts, alleging that an agreement between them amounts to illegal price fixing that cut reimbursements to independent pharmacies, according to Healthcare Dive. Those are allegations. Prime has defended the arrangement, and the case is separate from OIR’s examinations.

Florida is not the only state acting. According to Managed Healthcare Executive, nearly all states have laws on PBM licensing, pharmacy reimbursement or price transparency, and several have passed stricter rules in 2025 and 2026. Arkansas passed a 2025 law (Act 624) barring PBMs from owning pharmacies in the state, but a federal court blocked enforcement in July 2025 and the state’s appeal is pending at the Eighth Circuit, according to Mintz. California’s SB 41, signed in October 2025, bans spread pricing in PBM contracts starting January 1, 2026, voids existing spread pricing terms by 2029, and requires PBMs to pass through 100% of manufacturer rebates, according to AMCP. North Carolina’s 2025 law bars PBM contracts from paying independent pharmacies and pharmacies in pharmacy deserts less than their acquisition cost, according to the North Carolina Department of Insurance. What stands out about the Florida PBM penalties is the enforcement: mandatory examinations that ended in $12.66 million in penalties. If you live in another state, your state insurance department’s website is the place to see what its PBM law requires.

What do the Florida PBM penalties mean for your prescription costs?

The Florida PBM penalties address compliance with PBM rules. They are not a guarantee that your prescription costs will drop, and the reporting does not tie these fines to lower prices for any individual patient.

Most ACA Marketplace and employer plans use a PBM to run their pharmacy benefit. Coverage that is not insurance handles prescriptions differently, and two examples are worth knowing.

  • Direct Primary Care: Because a Direct Primary Care membership is a flat fee with the practice and not an insurance plan, it has no pharmacy benefit and no PBM. Some practices stock common medications and sell them in the office, in some cases at their own cost, while others send prescriptions to an outside pharmacy. Whether a practice can dispense depends on state rules, so ask what yours does.
  • Prescription programs offered with a Health Share: Some Health Shares offer members access to a prescription price comparison program, which compares prices across pharmacies so members can choose a lower cost option, often with a concierge to help. A program like this is a price comparison tool. It does not replace checking your own medications and prices.

What can you do to avoid prescription cost surprises?

Whatever coverage you have, a few checks before you enroll or refill can help:

  1. Check the formulary. Look up each of your medications on the plan’s drug list and note the tier or cost for each.
  2. Check the pharmacy network. Confirm that your regular pharmacy, including an independent pharmacy, is in network, and ask whether a mail order option is required.
  3. Compare prices. For a low cost generic, the cash price can sometimes be lower than your copay, so ask the pharmacy for both.
  4. Ask in writing. If you are looking at a Health Share or a membership program, ask how prescriptions are handled and get the answer in writing.

If you are comparing 2027 options, you can compare your coverage options by state and income. If your income is near the limit for tax credits, read about the ACA subsidy cliff. Floridians can also see our guide to individual health coverage options in Florida.

JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Buying your own coverage? You don’t have to figure it out alone.

Ask questions, compare notes and see what others are paying in our free Facebook group, get one plain-English email when something changes, or watch the 60-second explainers.

Join the Facebook group Get the newsletter Subscribe on YouTube

Frequently asked questions

What is a pharmacy benefit manager (PBM)? A PBM is a company that administers prescription drug benefits for a health plan or employer, including which drugs are covered, which pharmacies are in the network, and how pharmacies are paid.

Will the Florida PBM penalties lower my prescription costs? Not necessarily, and not immediately. The penalties address violations found during state examinations. No source ties these fines to a guaranteed reduction in what any individual patient pays.

Which companies were hit by the Florida PBM penalties? Thirteen companies were penalized: Employee Health Insurance Management, Scrip World, Right Rx FL, ProAct, Capital Rx, Slate Rx, Drexi, PerformRx, MC-21 Healthcare, Benecard Services, CarelonRx, Prime Therapeutics Management and Prime Therapeutics. Fines ranged from $5,000 to $2.415 million.

Is this related to the Florida lawsuit against Prime Therapeutics and Express Scripts? It is a related but separate matter. The OIR penalties come from administrative examinations. The Attorney General’s lawsuit alleges antitrust violations and was filed in court.

Do other states regulate PBMs? Yes. Nearly all states have PBM laws covering areas such as licensing, pharmacy reimbursement and price transparency, and several have passed stricter rules in 2025 and 2026.

Do PBM rules affect people with Health Shares or Direct Primary Care? They apply to how prescription benefits are administered under a health plan. Health Sharing and Direct Primary Care are not insurance, so ask your specific Health Share or practice how prescription costs are handled. Some Direct Primary Care practices dispense common medications in the office, and some Health Shares offer a prescription price comparison program.


This article is for general informational purposes only and is not insurance, legal, or financial advice. Reporting on Florida’s November 2026 PBM penalties comes from Insurance Business and Becker’s Payer Issues, with background from The Capitolist, Healthcare Dive, Managed Healthcare Executive, Mintz, AMCP and the North Carolina Department of Insurance. Health Sharing and Direct Primary Care arrangements are not insurance. All information is current as of November 2026. For the latest status of any PBM examination or enforcement action, confirm details with the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation.

By the Modern Healthcare Works team